Saturday, June 25, 2011

more links on shame

From Shame as the Master Emotion, http://www.newenglishreview.org/Thomas_J._Scheff/Shame_as_the_Master_Emotion%3A_Examples_from_Pop_Songs/ (bolds mine):
By an early age, most children have learned to understand speech not only from own point of view, but also from the point of view of the speaker. Comprehension depends on success in taking the role of the other, in reading their minds, so to speak.

Although there are many misses, [...]modern societies depend on a high rate of successful mind-reading. Considerable success must occur not only in conversation, but in most other settings as well[...]

Gradually the child gets so apt at guessing the other’s viewpoint and at going back and forth between the two points of view as to forget what he/she is doing. In forgetting, the child becomes the kind of adult that modern societies imagine us all to be, a self-contained individual. Reading others minds “without knowing it” enables modern societies to live by the myth of the self-reliant individual.

[...]a brilliant psychoanalyst, Helen Block Lewis (1971), provided a conception of shame that is equally social and individual. She proposed that shame is a signal of threat to the bond. This idea would give shame a social dimension as well as an internal one. Similarly, genuine pride (as contrasted with false pride, egotism) is a signal of a secure bond (connectedness). This idea includes the individualist one, since most of our positive feelings about ourselves involve reaching goals that are also held by others.

No comments: