Monday, December 20, 2010

the Garden, part two

reading about developmental stages:
“what you describe is actually pretty common. It occurs just about at the onset of puberty, when kids go into what Piaget called the age of abstract thought (and what religions call the Age of Reason). It's when you become aware of your consciousness as a separate entity from your physical being. Certainly there can be internal monologue before that happens, but that odd feeling of observing oneself is a function of new brain processes that come about as the brain matures.”
~Miko, 12/1/2004 http://ask.metafilter.com/12374/What-on-earth-is-going-on-in-childrens-heads

Wondering if there’s a correlation/parallel here between human species (?) evolution and developmental stages of human growth. I seem to remember reading somewhere that humans go through all the same phases while growing up that – oh, wait, maybe it’s that the developing embryo, in the womb? goes through all the ‘evolutionary’ changes that humans went through on the road from being some water-based critter to bipedality (?).

So I’m thinking: What if the ‘age of reason’ corresponds to that same point in human evolutionary history where we went from animals who had no ability to self-reflect to being the currently self-absorbed, self-obssessed, guilt-ridden creatures we are today?

Maybe that’s the ‘apple’ point, at which the fruit of the Tree is absorbed?

The painful, hyper-self-consciousness/awareness of teenagers; the development of the ongoing ‘internal monolog (or dialog???)’. Wonder what age that starts? I’m thinking around age 6? Don’t know why that age comes to mind, exactly.

***
It’s something to do with shame, and sexual shame, in particular.

Cultures which don’t develop this sexual shame (are there any left?) don’t become split into ‘good’ and ‘bad’ portions of themselves; they remain whole, integrated, as nature intended.

Those who find themselves judged, and thus end up being judges themselves, are also subject to shame.

Can’t quite capture this, it keeps escaping.

3 comments:

Michael Finley said...

For me the age of reason was pre-verbal. It was when I figured out that I could move an object and put it somewhere else in space.

It separated me from when I do this someone else moves an object.

I often wonder if I don't judge my self just a tad more harshly as a way to have me do it rather than someone else.

grasshopper said...

I think that's fairly common among self-judgers - if I've understood what you're saying, we 'pre-judge' ourselves to keep from getting hurt. Best defense is a good offense? Something like that.

For some reason the (I think Groucho Marx?) saying comes to mind, "I wouldn't belong to any club that would have me." I think those of us raised in harshly judgmental and critical environments are our own worst critics, for exactly the reason you say.

Michael Finley said...

"I wouldn't belong to any club that would have me."

Exactly!